Pegasus Pizza

Reviews

• Turok D.

  star star star star star 22 May 2026

  Amazing pizza. Amazing owners. Great staff.   I consider their Greek pizza one of the best pizzas ever. Especially for topping lovers.  Great texture. Wonderful flavor.  
  
  Paggliachi and Zeeks coming in as a close second and third.

• Mariah E.

  star star star star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  We ordered 2 fettuccines with prawns. My husband specifically mentioned he wanted a Caesar salad. I mentioned I wanted the salmon chowder.
  
  Only one salmon chowder came out. Then the lady brought out one fettuccine prawn for my husband... with a spoon...
  
  5 min later when she came back, I asked if my husband is going to get his salad and if I'm getting my fettuccine and she never even put the order in. She said oh ok I'll bring your salad out...
  
  What? I said I wanted a fettuccine with prawns 3x. She never listened.
  
  I can't with this place.
  
  This is the 4th time I came here where the service and food was just mediocre. I don't think I am going to come back here for awhile.
  
  The manager was kind enough to chime in. So I changed this review from 1 star to 3. I'm being generous.
  
  Me and my husband worked hard over the week and we wanted to enjoy our Friday evening on Alki beach. And this happens... I couldn't even eat with my own husband at the same time. What's the point of going on a dinner date?

• Christiana P.

  star star star star star_border 17 May 2026

  I was headed to a seafood restaurant on this same strip. But while walking by and looking at others customers food I decided to try it out. I also love anything with a theme. I ordered a Cesar salad the Hercules pizza. My drink was called Aphrodite and it was delicious. I don't drink as much as I used to otherwise I have had two more. The server, Ralaina, was really nice. We did a half and half pizza and they put onions on my side so it kind of ruined the taste for me. Everything else was great. They played 80s music and we sat outside. I really enjoyed the experience.

• Zachary K.

  star star star star star_border 8 May 2026

  Service was good. Got the Pegasus Special which was great. Their prices have gone up but you get plenty of toppings and cheese.
  Would not get the Shrimp Salad again as we both didn't feel well right after we left.

• Tracy A.

  star star star star star_border 6 May 2026

  Great location at Alki Beach with outdoor seating and waterfront view.  The staff is super friendly, and the bartender is fun.  If you give her the go ahead, she'll make up a drink for you.  I had a version of a French 75 that was great.  I think the highlight of the pizza here is the shredded pepperoni which is fantastic if you like it crispy almost to a well done bacon characteristic.  I loved the pepperoni!  The pizza was good.  I would like a choice option in crust because I am starting to really like thin crust, and Pegasus is a little bit thicker but soft crust and still good. We had the Tom special which had several toppings including feta cheese. Definitely a repeat visit for me.